Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 6, No. 2, 2007
A Response to James D. Chancellor’s Life in The Family: An Oral
History of the Children of God
Perry Bulwer, B.A., LL.B.
Abstract
James D. Chancellor’s book is
considered by some to be the best academic overview of The Family to date.
Chancellor’s stated purpose was to provide a “clear, self-portrait of an
intriguing and unique community.” However, he acknowledges that his work is not
the whole story and that The Family requires a broader assessment from academics
as well as former members. This article attempts to provide part of that broader
assessment by challenging some of Chancellor’s conclusions and interpretation of
facts, and by considering some of the more important omissions from his account
of The Family’s history. Chancellor’s methodology necessarily omits from his
portrait important details concerning The Family’s authoritarian leadership and
the direct role of past and current leaders in the abuse of numerous children
and adolescents. Furthermore, by documenting The Family’s practice of deceiving
outsiders, including scholars and legal authorities, as to its true nature, this
article provides direct evidence that The Family is not entirely as Chancellor
and his interviewees make it out to be.
Full text available through
ICSA E-Library. Also
available in e-Library: James Chancellor's response and Perry Bulwer's reply to
Chancellor.
|